Hope Scholarship or Traditional Homeschool? How a Hope IIP Student Differs From a Homeschooler
By My Learning Source · November 22, 2026 · Scholarships, Guides, Parenting
Many West Virginia parents assume that if they teach their children at home, they are homeschooling, whatever the funding source. Under state law, that is not quite right. A child who learns at home with Hope Scholarship money is usually a Hope student on an Individualized Instructional Program, or IIP. A child taught at home without Hope money is a homeschooler under the notice of intent exemption. They look alike at the kitchen table. They follow different rules on paper.
Two different exemptions
West Virginia's compulsory attendance law, §18-8-1, lists the ways a child can be excused from public school. Traditional home instruction is subsection (c). Hope Scholarship participation is subsection (m). The Hope Act's definition of an IIP in §18-31-2 says IIP students are governed by the Hope Act and "not any other compulsory school attendance exemption requirements." The Hope Board's FAQ puts it simply: the two are legally different exemptions.
The Act also says the reverse. §18-31-2a states that nothing in it subjects homeschool students who are not in the Hope program to Hope requirements. Taking no state money keeps you under the homeschool statute only.
Side by side
- The notice. Homeschool: a one-time notice of intent to the county superintendent with each child's name, address and age, plus an assurance of instruction in reading, language, mathematics, science and social studies. Hope: a separate Hope Scholarship notice of intent, filed after the application reaches Eligible status, marking the IIP pathway.
- Parent qualifications. Homeschool: the teaching parent must show a high school diploma or equivalent, or a qualifying postsecondary degree or certificate. Hope: the Act itself has no parent diploma requirement; the parent signs the Hope agreement instead.
- Annual assessment. Homeschool: every year, using one of four options, including a standardized test, the state test at a public school, a certified teacher portfolio review or an alternative the superintendent agrees to. Hope IIP: every year, either a nationally normed achievement test or a certified teacher's review of the student's work.
- Reporting. Homeschool: results go to the county only in grades 3, 5, 8 and 11, by June 30. Hope IIP: results go to the county every year, and the FAQ sets a June 8 deadline.
- Testing standard. Both use the fourth stanine, or improvement from the year before, as the passing line for tests. Hope testing covers reading, language and math, plus science and social studies when available for the grade.
- Money. Homeschool: none from the state. Hope: $5,435.62 for a full 2026-27 award, spent through the portal.
- Consequences. Homeschool: failing to show acceptable progress means starting a remedial program, and a second consecutive year requires more evidence to the superintendent. Hope: failing to meet the annual academic and attendance reporting can close the account.
Things both keep
Hope IIP students keep the privileges that homeschoolers have. Section 18-31-2a lists several: a diploma from the student's program administrator under §18-8-12, eligibility for the PROMISE Scholarship, a work permit without prior review by a school administrator and access to the ACE program. Both groups are also eligible for interscholastic athletics under §18-2-25, subject to the same academic progress standard.
Switching from homeschool to Hope
The FAQ gives a clear sequence. Finish the current year under the homeschool exemption, including any grade 3, 5, 8 or 11 assessment due by June 30. Once the Hope application is Eligible, send the county a Hope notice of intent for the new school year and a notice of termination of homeschooling. The sample Hope notice of intent has an optional section that does both. Do not leave a gap where your child is under neither exemption.
Special education
The two paths treat disabilities differently. A traditional homeschooler keeps the protections in §18-8-1: the county must, on request, tell parents in writing about services to help assess eligibility for special education, and identifying a disability does not end homeschooling. The Hope Board's FAQ says Hope participation is a parental placement under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which releases the county from its duty to provide a free appropriate public education while the child is in the program. If your child has an IEP, read Policy 2419 and talk with your county before choosing Hope.
Which one is more paperwork?
For most families, Hope is more paperwork in exchange for money. The traditional route asks for one notice, proof of your diploma and a test or portfolio review four times across a child's schooling. Hope asks for an application, a separate notice, a yearly progress report to the county by June 8, a yearly continued participation confirmation by June 15 and portal record-keeping for every purchase. Some families find that trade easy. Others decide the freedom of the traditional route is worth more than the award.
Switching back
If Hope does not work out, you can leave the program, notify the Board and file a regular homeschool notice of intent with your county. Remaining funds return to the state. If you later want Hope again, you reapply as a new applicant, and the award will depend on which window you apply in.
A family comparing
The Mullinses in Wayne County have taught three children at home for six years. Their oldest is in 11th grade, and they were going to submit a test score that year anyway. Their middle child struggles with tests, so they liked that Hope accepts a certified teacher's review of the year's work. They switched the middle child to Hope, kept their oldest under the homeschool exemption for one last year to avoid new paperwork, and planned to decide about the youngest after seeing how the yearly June 8 reporting went.
(A composite example — names and details are illustrative, drawn from situations homeschool families commonly describe.)
Questions to ask yourself
- Are we comfortable reporting academic progress to the county every year instead of four times in a child's schooling?
- Will the money cover things we would buy anyway, such as curriculum, tests and classes?
- Do the providers we use already participate? Check our vendor directory and the Hope portal.
- Can we keep up with portal purchasing, the June 15 renewal and the quarterly funding cutoffs?
- Would a mixed approach, with Hope for one child and traditional homeschooling for another, make sense?
Read the WVDE summary of the homeschool law and our Hope Scholarship guide side by side before you decide.
My Learning Source is an independent marketplace and is not affiliated with the West Virginia Hope Scholarship Board, the West Virginia State Treasurer's Office, the West Virginia Department of Education, Student First Technologies or any county board of education. The two exemptions have different rules that can change — confirm requirements with your county board of education and the Hope Scholarship Board before you switch. Family examples are composites, not real individuals.